A
Lesson in Political Science
Hello
There
is so much talk and arguments and counter-arguments everywhere, but even learned
media people and scholars fail to see the basic facts for what they are.
Please enlighten them.
Henry
Kissinger said: There is never a Foreign Policy;
Only Domestic Policy.
It
means: If you want to really
understand the actions of leaders and politicians, never listen to their
foreign policy
statements; Instead, examine closely their domestic
constraints and pressures, and you will understand the
REAL reasons behind their actions.
Case in
Point:
The
REAL Reason Arafat turned down the Palestinian State offered him in 2000 at
Camp David
Barak, Clinton &
Arafat
at Camp David
1.
Arafat founded his PLO organization in 1964. Its fundamental tenet was: to
destroy the State of Israel and to return the refugees to the places they
demanded inside Israel (Right of Return).
(No
mention of a Palestinian State then; this came much later).
2.
Since then Arafat became a prisoner of his own rhetoric. In Camp David he was
offered virtually everything EXCEPT the right of return of the Palestinian
refugees to Israel proper. If he had taken the offer, he would be considered a
traitor who went back on his basic tenet and would be promptly shot in the
head.
3.
So Arafat turned down the Camp David agreement simply to stay
alive.
The
REAL reason Arafat utterly blew his chance
to
become the leader of a Palestinian State
Marwan Barghoutti,
Tanzim Haled Mashal, Hamas (with
Hezbollah's Jibril
Rajoub,
Nasrallah) Preventinve
Security,
West
bank
Tawfik Tirawi, Palestinian
Muhammad
Dahlan,
Ramadan Abdullah Nasser Abu Hamid, Al
General
Intelligence Preventive
Security, Gaza Shalla, Islamic
Jihad Martyrs Brigade (picture absent)
1.
In the Oslo Accords signed in 1993, Arafat pledged to crack down on
terrorist groups and ensure an end to terrorism.
2.
From a PALESTINIAN AUTHORITY point of view, such a step was vital in order to
ensure that the PA can actually control and rule the territories handed to it,
with no independent 'private armies' constantly challenging its
authority.
3.
To achieve this, the PA was given permission to establish its own armed police
force (actually an army) and the weapons for this force were supplied by
Israel.
3.
Fact: After Israel was established and the Israel Defense Force was established,
the State's first Prime Minister David Ben Gurion did not hesitate to: (A)
dismantle the Palmach
(the military arm of the Hagana -
Largest Jewish pre-state defense organization), and also
open fire on the arms ship Altalena
which brought arms to the Etzel
Second Jewish military organization, and sink the ship.
Ben
Gurion said: "There is only one Israeli Defense Force. There will be no
independent armies. The Armed Forces will be subordinate to the Government of
Israel only and to no one else".
This
was proven historically right, to consolidate a democratic government and not
allow an anarchy of disparate armed factions setting their own
agenda.
4.
Arafat did not do it. Despite the opportunity he was given, and the weapons he
was given, he neither dismantled nor cracked down on the Hamas and the Jihad.
Moreover: he let his own security forces
develop into an unruly assortment of autonomous armed
gangs with numerous gang-leaders, each setting up his own
agenda.
(For
example, Marwan Barghoutti, head of the Tanzim armed militia of the PLO, was one
of the main instigators of the Sept. 2000 intifada, while Jibril Rajoub, head of
the PA preventive security armed force, refrained from taking part in the
intifada).
5.
This was the exact process by which Arafat blew his chance to consolidate one
centralized power, with one centralized armed force subordinate only to the
government, which is the one essential pre-requisite to the formation of a
Sovereign State.
The
REAL reason Arafat started the intifada
right
after the Camp David summit
Slaughtered
victims at the Cafe Moment Homicide Bombing in Jerusalem, March 9,
2002
1.
Having allowed numerous armed factions to develop and amass power, Arafat
found himself facing a pack of hungry wolves vying for his
throne.
2.
His own authority at stake and his chair shaky, Arafat pulled the oldest
trick in every dictator's book: When faced with internal
turmoil, designate an external enemy and send all parties after him, to
avert the wrath that will otherwise be directed against
you.
3.
So Arafat started an intifada against an external enemy (Israel) only to avert
the danger imminent upon his own throne. He sent the different armed factions to
compete among themselves as to who commits more terrorist attacks against
Israeli civilians. It became the national sport, with a weekly league tallying
the "scores" and announcing the weekly champion. It received active
encouragement of the PA controlled media and from Arafat himself in
his 'motivation' speeches. It received direct financing from the PA itself,
Iraq, Iran and Saudi Arabia. It united the Palestinian people against one
external "enemy" who has just offered them a free independent
state.
4.
This 'national sport' of terrorist attacks, fuelled by a fundamentalist Moslem
ideology, got out of hand and forced Israel to take military steps to curb
it.
5.
The current situation is that there is no actual Head of the Palestinian entity
anyone can talk to and reach an agreement with. It is a violent anarchy. Arafat
today is little more than a symbol.
Summary:
1. Like every average politician who's prime objective is always to retain his
position and not lose it, Arafat turned down the Palestinian State offered
him at Camp David and started the intifada to: (A) avoid being overthrown
from power; (B) stay alive.
2. Even today, everything Arafat says or does is only for his own political and
personal survival. Follow it and you will see for yourself.
3. If we also wanted to ascribe any measure of Integrity to Arafat, we could say
that Arafat did not betray the basic credo he has been fighting for all his life,
namely: the destruction of the State of Israel.
If this is the case, it makes Arafat no different than Hamas.
Israelis Want Peace. Terror Kills Peace.
Please
pass it to people who write or talk in the media, so that they will be better
informed on the real picture.
Please
pass it on to people in campuses.
Please
pass it on to everyone you know.
Motti
Morell